Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.
Welcome Guest Search | Active Topics | Members | Log In | Register

BOXING THREAD ??? Options
usherprince
Posted: Tuesday, November 04, 2008 9:58:22 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 5/22/2008
Posts: 1,994
Location: Australia
bateman wrote:
The Hopkins Fight is a great example why fans are leaving Boxing and going to MMA.

A 12 round snoozefest

just like the Mundine/Green Fight

or The Lewis/Tua Fight


Comparing Lewis/Tua with Hopkins/Pavlik is beyond stupid.

It shows your lack of boxing knowledge to claim the Hopkins fight was boring. You are like the many fans out there who think a boxing fight has to have knockouts and big hits for it to be a 'exciting' fight. You are probably the same type of person who changes the channel once a MMA fight goes to the floor and it the grappling starts.

The Hopkins fight was one of the best fights I've seen this year. Watching him completely school Pavlik and dominant the way he did had me in awe/shock the entire fight.
Megadeecee
Posted: Tuesday, November 04, 2008 10:28:04 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/24/2008
Posts: 1,073
Location: Bungle Bungles
The Sweet Science And UFC are both great. I've Heard The Reason why Boxing Is Going downhill is because people Like "Marvellous" Marvin Had To Defend Their Title Again And Again just to make some decent money. Now They only have to be around for a couple years at the top and there multi millionaires . No need to keep going when you can live the highlife without the hard training and getting smashed . Also I hate The wrestlers in UFC Winning on the ground should be a last resort not a planned thing imo. I am a big fan of The "Real Deal" Amongst Many Many Others I Remember thinking before First Tyson Fight When he was in the Dressing room singing hallelujah type stuff beforehand He Was gonna get bashed to death biggest upset i've seen along with Foreman '94 But I've Heard Larry Holmes Say he's was on Steroids maybe that is another reason why they don't last at the top as long unless they pick their fights so carefully like Mundine and Calzaghe . I think most are these days people like the UFC's Ortiz Have Roid "Jaw".
bateman
Posted: Tuesday, November 04, 2008 10:49:41 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/23/2005
Posts: 3,089
usherprince wrote:


Comparing Lewis/Tua with Hopkins/Pavlik is beyond stupid.

It shows your lack of boxing knowledge to claim the Hopkins fight was boring. You are like the many fans out there who think a boxing fight has to have knockouts and big hits for it to be a 'exciting' fight. You are probably the same type of person who changes the channel once a MMA fight goes to the floor and it the grappling starts.

The Hopkins fight was one of the best fights I've seen this year. Watching him completely school Pavlik and dominant the way he did had me in awe/shock the entire fight.


A classic diehard, arrogant boxing fans argument... Avoid criticism by knocking someone's boxing knowledge without having a clue who they are.


blah blah blah, sweet science B.S....The fact is Hopkins totally outclassed Pavlik...Totally, not just in boxing skills, but intensity,desire, FITNESS in Everything beyond believe... Pavlik is a man half his age, this shouldn't happen! This show's the lack of talent coming through....either that or it was a pay day(nothing new in boxing)

If you think that the Hopkins fight was great, you probably enjoyed the Manly GF final too...total floggings, I on the other hand like a contest.

And the Lewis/Tua fight has a LOT of Comparisons to the Hopkins fight. So maybe YOU need a history lesson. Both Fights promised A LOT...offered little , both had an up and coming fighter who had very impressive records and 'KO power' but who then ended up being a punching bag for 12 rounds. And a older Fighter, who while having better skills and hand speed, has no intentions of actually getting into a 'fight'!

(and nice how you conveniently forgot to mention my other comparison of the Mundine V Green borefest..cause you know Im right!)

*********

As for UFC only being about KO's you again show how outta touch you really are. If you wanna some get there head knocked in backwards watch boxing!

It isn't the big hits which turn people over to MMA... it's not... at all.....It's the Unpredictability of the fights!... there's so many ways to win...It's getting an honest result and Contest, with no Don King B.S...



And as im a Gracie Purple Belt why would I be changing the channel when the fight goes to the ground, remember UFC one???.......Art Jimmerson??? Laughing Laughing Laughing

But please....Continue .... boxing's in great shape because....Laughing

Fumez
Posted: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 12:16:10 AM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 10/11/2007
Posts: 285
Location: Melbourne
Whilst im a fan of Boxing i do tend to agree with what your saying to an extent the depth in boxing is quite thin atm. Probably the weakest it has been in a long time....especially when you follow that with what we were blessed with in the 90s. some of the best Holyfield,Lewis,Tyson,Bowe, Jones,Hopkins,Morales, Oscar,Mosley,Trinidad,Chavez,Barrera, to name but a few...the match ups Holyfield vs Bowe. Barrera vs Morales,Oscar Vs Mosley etc....a lot of high quality fights...hard to match that era these days the only standout is Mayweather...number 2 its Calzaghe but he is a distant 2nd because a prime Hopkins and Jones would wipe the floor with him. Boxing does need a new epic rivalry such Holyfield vs Bowe or Barrera vs Morales or even a Gatti vs Ward.
the current heavyweight champion Waldmier would be ripped in half by a prime Holyfield, Lewis and Tyson. He would last 3 rounds with that glass jaw. Lets hope boxing does find some true champions of the sport in the near future. Its no wonder Mayweather retired he has nothing left to prove he has beaten everyone and now only has c grade opponents, what would be his motivation?
kremmen
Posted: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 10:35:14 AM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/11/2005
Posts: 326
Location: brisbane
bateman wrote:
The Hopkins Fight is a great example why fans are leaving Boxing and going to MMA.

A 12 round snoozefest

just like the Mundine/Green Fight

or The Lewis/Tua Fight


huh?

I thought the hopkins fight was great. Seeing the old bull school the young buck. It was going to be interesting to see how pavlik came up in weight for the fight.

Your choice of comparitive fights are interesting to say the least?

When was the mundine green ever going to be a great fight???? Both overrated and nobodies on the world scene really.

Lewis Tua? Why bring this up? what relevance do two heavyweights have with a middle weight coming up in weight to fight a lt heavy coming down in weight??

Why dont you now list every "yawnfest" MMA fight that goes to ground after 30 seconds.

I prefer boxing, but i don't feel the need to bag MMA, or follow it because its cool man...

Boxing has and will be around for a lot longer than mma
usherprince
Posted: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 12:37:32 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 5/22/2008
Posts: 1,994
Location: Australia
bateman wrote:


A classic diehard, arrogant boxing fans argument... Avoid criticism by knocking someone's boxing knowledge without having a clue who they are.

blah blah blah, sweet science B.S....The fact is Hopkins totally outclassed Pavlik...Totally, not just in boxing skills, but intensity,desire, FITNESS in Everything beyond believe... Pavlik is a man half his age, this shouldn't happen! This show's the lack of talent coming through....either that or it was a pay day(nothing new in boxing)

If you think that the Hopkins fight was great, you probably enjoyed the Manly GF final too...total floggings, I on the other hand like a contest.

And the Lewis/Tua fight has a LOT of Comparisons to the Hopkins fight. So maybe YOU need a history lesson. Both Fights promised A LOT...offered little , both had an up and coming fighter who had very impressive records and 'KO power' but who then ended up being a punching bag for 12 rounds. And a older Fighter, who while having better skills and hand speed, has no intentions of actually getting into a 'fight'!

(and nice how you conveniently forgot to mention my other comparison of the Mundine V Green borefest..cause you know Im right!)

*********

As for UFC only being about KO's you again show how outta touch you really are. If you wanna some get there head knocked in backwards watch boxing!

It isn't the big hits which turn people over to MMA... it's not... at all.....It's the Unpredictability of the fights!... there's so many ways to win...It's getting an honest result and Contest, with no Don King B.S...


And as im a Gracie Purple Belt why would I be changing the channel when the fight goes to the ground, remember UFC one???.......Art Jimmerson??? Laughing Laughing Laughing

But please....Continue .... boxing's in great shape because....Laughing


I was like you and never gave Hopkins a chance of beating Pavlik (hence why I had $500 on Pavlik). But like you said, Hopkins completely outboxed him in every facet. But your argument that it proves a 'lack of talent' coming through is laughable. You don't reckon it was because Pavlik went up 2 weight divisions?, or because he never fought anyone of the calire & tenaciousness of Hopkins?, or, most importantly, that Hopkins managed to somehow pull out the performance of his distinguished career.

Watching a 40+ legend dominate a guy almost half his age is exactly why boxing is so great.
WTF is with your comparison to a rugby league grand final??? League and boxing have NOTHING in common AT ALL, why you would bring that up is beyond me.

And Lewis/Tua was NOTHING like the Hopkins fight. Pavlik was a top 5 pound-for-pound boxer in the world before the Hopkins fight. Pavlik will go back down to Middleweight (where he should be) and dominant for years to come. Tua was a knockout side-show, has no boxing talent. He did fuck all before the Lewis fight, and has done fuck all since. Meanwhile, Lewis was in the prime of his career, and was odds-on favourite to win the fight. No one gave Hopkins a chance.

When did I critised UFC or MMA?? Quite the opposite, i'm a huge fan of MMA, have trained in it for several years. I merely pointed out the amount of fans out there that quickly loose interest in MMA once it goes to the ground. And if you disagree with this, then you obviously have never been to a live MMA tournament. Go watch a local XFC fight night and watch the amount of groans and booos you get once a fight goes to the ground.

Exactly like kremmen said, I prefer boxing but feel no need whatsoever to bad MMA. I'm sure I could go through a heap of the UFC mainevents and fight what you would call 5 round 'snoozefests'. But thats what you get with boxing & UFC. Unfortunately not every fight can be a Corralles vs Castillo.
bateman
Posted: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 1:31:56 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/23/2005
Posts: 3,089
Fumez wrote:
Mayweather retired he has nothing left to prove he has beaten everyone and now only has c grade opponents, what would be his motivation?



$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$


he's a great boxer but he'll be back... Like RJJ and hopkins......he'll come back for a pay day, nothing more...
bateman
Posted: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 1:44:06 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/23/2005
Posts: 3,089


kremmen wrote:

Your choice of comparitive fights are interesting to say the least?

When was the mundine green ever going to be a great fight???? Both overrated and nobodies on the world scene really.

Lewis Tua? Why bring this up? what relevance do two heavyweights have with a middle weight coming up in weight to fight a lt heavy coming down in weight??


Mundine Fight was the Biggest Fight in Australian History...while I serious doubts about the quality of the fighters and (the honestly of the outcome) ... it was a Huge Fight (it was at the SFS) again the match up of A powerful striker V 'skilled' boxer... Same Result Green became a punching bag for 12 rounds... mundine well...if man can hold a world boxing title... That a BIG shame for Boxing.

Lewis/tua was the same... 12 rounds of nothing.

I guess my biggest problem his how they rob the fans, promote these fights as going to be huge... the outcomes are very questionable.

Also MMA has been around just as long as Boxing... if not longer....

But I respect your opinion and the civil manner in which you can discuss this topic in.

bateman
Posted: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 2:16:54 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/23/2005
Posts: 3,089
usherprince wrote:

But your argument that it proves a 'lack of talent' coming through is laughable.


common, all of pro boxing is suffering from a lack of talent. Maybe not in traditional places like Mexico or Cuba, but in the pro's...hell yeah.

like the other guy said, it was Money Mayweather then a country mile, he was only 31 and he's retired.


and if wasn't for BIG money and the 90's stars ... you won't have any big fights anymore, cause recently it all been about old fighters making a come. Hopkins, RJJ... these are the only fights drawing big crowds. Cause there isn't any new superstar boxers.



FFS Klitchko want to fight Rahman who is so crap ...but cause he was 'semi' famous a decade ago, it will draw a crowd.


usherprince wrote:

WTF is with your comparison to a rugby league grand final??? League and boxing have NOTHING in common AT ALL, why you would bring that up is beyond me.


I was making the point that it promised to be a battle, but was a total flogging. Like the Hopkins fight, totally one sided. I don't enjoy watching a one side affair...it's just not a contest...
usherprince wrote:


you obviously have never been to a live MMA tournament. Go watch a local XFC fight night and watch the amount of groans and booos you get once a fight goes to the ground.


those people are morons, come to see blood and nothing more. You probably get them in Boxing too. True MMA fans love all aspect of the sport, heard of vale tudo, that's what I talking about.
usherprince wrote:


Corralles vs Castillo.


That's the problem, a freak show in Boxing gets more attention that a great fight. I admit some MMA org's are the same, But So far the UFC roster is impressive.
usherprince
Posted: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 4:20:45 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 5/22/2008
Posts: 1,994
Location: Australia
bateman wrote:

common, all of pro boxing is suffering from a lack of talent. Maybe not in traditional places like Mexico or Cuba, but in the pro's...hell yeah.

like the other guy said, it was Money Mayweather then a country mile, he was only 31 and he's retired.


and if wasn't for BIG money and the 90's stars ... you won't have any big fights anymore, cause recently it all been about old fighters making a come. Hopkins, RJJ... these are the only fights drawing big crowds. Cause there isn't any new superstar boxers.


FFS Klitchko want to fight Rahman who is so ***** ...but cause he was 'semi' famous a decade ago, it will draw a crowd.


Unfortunately the same could be said with UFC. Anderson Silva is carrying UFC at the moment. So using the same argument as you, I guess you could say the UFC is lacking talent atm.

And I agree with you completely about the heavyweight atm. Its a giant shame. Hopefully Klitscko can bring a bit of credibility back. But the real talent at the moment is in the lower weight divisions.

Oh and you're dreaming if you think Money Mayweather is 'retired'!! There's a reason he's called 'Money'. He'll be back

bateman wrote:
those people are morons, come to see blood and nothing more. You probably get them in Boxing too. True MMA fans love all aspect of the sport, heard of vale tudo, that's what I talking about.

Exactly! Thats the point I was making in the other thread. As a MMA supporter, you obviously get fustrated by those 'fans' who expect to see blood every fight. They don't appreciate the finer art that is MMA. So when you came out and posted that rant about the Hopkins/Pavlik fight, you came across as exactly the same as one of those 'fans'. Yeh there was no KO and it wasn't a close fight, but it was 2 very talented fighters showing off the true art of boxing.

bateman wrote:
That's the problem, a freak show in Boxing gets more attention that a great fight. I admit some MMA org's are the same, But So far the UFC roster is impressive.


If its so impressive, why the fuck are Liddell, Coulture, Ortiz, Hughes, etc still getting the main event fights? They are the MMA's version of de la Hoya, RJJ...Of course they are past their prime, but they still draw crowds and can still put on a show. I have no interest for Coulture anymore, I wished he'd retire, but he keeps fighting and you can't blame him with the $$ he's getting.
k.hunt
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 8:25:00 AM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/26/2008
Posts: 2,348
Location: sydnney
mundine versus some cab driver tonight out at liverpool of all places.

anyone going,watching,punting,caring?
usherprince
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 11:21:00 AM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 5/22/2008
Posts: 1,994
Location: Australia
k.hunt wrote:
mundine versus some cab driver tonight out at liverpool of all places.

anyone going,watching,punting,caring?


I'll be watching on PPV. I'm a Mundine fan, never missed a fight.

I would punt on it but the only option I can find on Sportingbet is Mundine to win @ 1.04. Wanted to bet on a 4th round knockout

k.hunt
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 12:31:55 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/26/2008
Posts: 2,348
Location: sydnney
usherprince wrote:


I'll be watching on PPV. I'm a Mundine fan, never missed a fight.

I would punt on it but the only option I can find on Sportingbet is Mundine to win @ 1.04. Wanted to bet on a 4th round knockout



lol load up!

ive seen his fights aswell.been to quite a few too.
kremmen
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 4:08:37 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/11/2005
Posts: 326
Location: brisbane
k.hunt wrote:
mundine versus some cab driver tonight out at liverpool of all places.

anyone going,watching,punting,caring?


Nope. I vowed never to watch another mundine fight years ago. Not going to make him rich watching him fight potato sacks.

I will watch sakio bika fight manfedo jr (if i can find anywhere that shows it)

or Lovemore Ndou V Clintron on Sky 12:30 sunday.

these fights will actually be a worthwhile contest.
usherprince
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 6:21:28 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 5/22/2008
Posts: 1,994
Location: Australia
kremmen wrote:


Nope. I vowed never to watch another mundine fight years ago. Not going to make him rich watching him fight potato sacks.

I will watch sakio bika fight manfedo jr (if i can find anywhere that shows it)

or Lovemore Ndou V Clintron on Sky 12:30 sunday.

these fights will actually be a worthwhile contest.


Bika v Manfredo will not be a 'worthwhile' contest. Only reason it will draw a crowd is because of the 'reality TV' factor.
The Contender is yet to prove someone of world-class talent, and thats been proving by all the fighters going NOWHERE since the fight. Who the fuck is Grady Brewer? Oh thats right, he WON series 2. Sergio Mora at least 'won' a 'title', but Forrest proved that to be a fluke. Ishe Smith was the only one that I saw having a future, but he lost early on in series one and since then has struggled to get big name fights.

MANFREDO IS A JOKE. How does this guy keep getting big fights???? He's living off the hype of the Contender. Granted Bika is a good fighter, his fight against Beyer & Calzaghe proved that. But again he is suffering from the Contender curse. Name me a top fighter he has beaten? Ndou is also a very talented fighter, but again, who has he beaten? Yeh he went close against Malignaggi, but still lost.

Both these fighters are falling into the trap of baiting Mundine, hoping to make a name of himself. As good a fighter as they are, they wouldn't offer Mundine much of a challange, for the sole reason that they are too smalll. The only Aussie I see challenging Mundine is Danny Green, and only if they fought at light-heavy or catchweight.
And before you all come out saying "Mundines scared, Biko/Ndou would kick his arse", just remember so-called top quality Aussie boxers like Soliman, Thornberry, & Mayo. And look how they fared against Mundine.

You're right though, Mundine is getting rich fighting potato sacks. if I wasn't a Mundine supporter I wouldn't bother with the fight. But same can be said about the other two fights. I don't even know if i'd put myself through the tortue of watching Manfredo fight, even if it was free
Drop Bear
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 6:24:28 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 10/26/2008
Posts: 347
Location: North of the Yarra
The main problem with boxing in my opinion is that there're too many "world titles" these days. I'd love there to be just one title per division. It's a prime example of money ruining a sport.
kremmen
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 9:57:10 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/11/2005
Posts: 326
Location: brisbane
usherprince wrote:


Bika v Manfredo will not be a 'worthwhile' contest. Only reason it will draw a crowd is because of the 'reality TV' factor.
The Contender is yet to prove someone of world-class talent, and thats been proving by all the fighters going NOWHERE since the fight. Who the fuck is Grady Brewer? Oh thats right, he WON series 2. Sergio Mora at least 'won' a 'title', but Forrest proved that to be a fluke. Ishe Smith was the only one that I saw having a future, but he lost early on in series one and since then has struggled to get big name fights.

MANFREDO IS A JOKE. How does this guy keep getting big fights???? He's living off the hype of the Contender. Granted Bika is a good fighter, his fight against Beyer & Calzaghe proved that. But again he is suffering from the Contender curse. Name me a top fighter he has beaten? Ndou is also a very talented fighter, but again, who has he beaten? Yeh he went close against Malignaggi, but still lost.

Both these fighters are falling into the trap of baiting Mundine, hoping to make a name of himself. As good a fighter as they are, they wouldn't offer Mundine much of a challange, for the sole reason that they are too smalll. The only Aussie I see challenging Mundine is Danny Green, and only if they fought at light-heavy or catchweight.
And before you all come out saying "Mundines scared, Biko/Ndou would kick his arse", just remember so-called top quality Aussie boxers like Soliman, Thornberry, & Mayo. And look how they fared against Mundine.

You're right though, Mundine is getting rich fighting potato sacks. if I wasn't a Mundine supporter I wouldn't bother with the fight. But same can be said about the other two fights. I don't even know if i'd put myself through the tortue of watching Manfredo fight, even if it was free


Name a top fighter mundine has beaten.
Bika too small for mundine? He's 6 foot 1. At super middle it would be a good fight, but he needs a few fights as he has done sfa the last 18 months.
Ndou wouldn't beat mundine he is too small & getting pold now. A lot of his early fights were taken on very short notice and he has fought some big name fighters. His fightt against clintron will be good. But i never said either of these two would beat mundine, I just said those two fights will be more of a contest than mundine fighting an unemployed uruguyan cab driver.
Ice
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 10:44:27 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/8/2007
Posts: 1,773
Location: Canberra
I'm no boxing guru but i am just curious, which fighters is it that Mundine is refusing to fight. If my memory serves me most people used to nail him non stop cause he wouldn't fight Green. He did that and won comfortably and basically sent the guy into retirement. So who is it that he is now not willing to fight??

Like i said i don't know much about it so would be curious to know who he is running from and what other fighters in his division are doing and who they are beating over the course of a 36 career fight.

By the by, how did he go tonight?
Stevie G
Posted: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 11:20:12 PM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/5/2007
Posts: 485
Location: in the bush near Melwood
Mundine - unanimous decision
south01
Posted: Thursday, November 13, 2008 8:57:09 AM
Rank: Sports Guru
Groups: Member , Moderator

Joined: 3/26/2008
Posts: 4,434
Location: melbourne
k.hunt wrote:
mundine versus some cab driver tonight out at liverpool of all places.

anyone going,watching,punting,caring?
i didnt even know this was on...
Users browsing this topic
Guest


Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Main Forum RSS : RSS


Copyright © 2009 Sportal Australia. All rights reserved.

28 queries (0.392 seconds, 32.18%).

yaf_pageload: 0.019
yaf_topic_info: 0.010
yaf_forum_list: 0.013
yaf_forum_listpath: 0.011
yaf_forum_listpath: 0.010
yaf_post_list: 0.033
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.011
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.012
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.011
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.010
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.032
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.025
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.020
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.010
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.009
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.009
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.012
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.015
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.011
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.011
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.013
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.011
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.012
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.011
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.011
yaf_usergroup_list: 0.012
yaf_topic_simplelist: 0.017
yaf_active_listtopic: 0.011